Articles

Your Brand Strategy Is Poker, Not Chess

Your Brand Strategy Is Poker, Not Chess

When people hear the word strategy, their minds often jump to chess. A black-and-white board. Equal information. Cold logic. Predictable outcomes. It’s a neat metaphor — but it’s the wrong one for understanding brand strategy. In reality, brand strategy isn’t about playing with all the facts. It’s about making confident moves in an unpredictable game.

Chess is deterministic. Poker is probabilistic.

In chess, all the pieces are visible. Both players can see the entire board. Every move is open to analysis. The best player usually wins — not because they’re lucky, but because they’ve made better decisions.

In poker, the opposite is true. Players act on partial information. Only you know your hand — and what’s visible on the table — but not what’s hidden in your opponents’ hands or minds. One can play perfectly and still lose. You can play recklessly and still win. Even elite poker players win only about 60% of the time across a full session.

Now ask yourself: Which of these feels more like the real world of branding?

Branding is poker. The stakes are real, and you don’t control everything.

Your brand lives in the minds of your audience. It’s built on expectations, not assets. That’s why we often ask clients in workshops to swap the word brand for expectation. When you make that shift, everything changes.

You don’t know:

  • What cards your competitors are holding — their tech stack, human capital, or secret partnerships.

  • What algorithm updates might bury your content marketing overnight.

  • What economic or political ripple, thousands of kilometres away, might upend your perfectly timed campaign.

Even if you make all the right moves — great strategy, clean execution — your audience might not see it, care about it, or trust it yet. Just like poker, there are hands where the river turns against you at the last moment.

The 2017-2018 Listeriosis Outbreak

In 2017–2018, South Africa experienced the world’s deadliest listeriosis outbreak, traced to processed meats produced by Enterprise Foods, a subsidiary of Tiger Brands, at their Polokwane facility. The outbreak resulted in over 1,000 confirmed cases and more than 200 deaths.

Despite having no involvement, Eskort — another processed meat brand — suffered significant collateral damage. Consumers, confused by similar red logos and the shared initial “E” in their brand names, incorrectly associated Eskort with the outbreak. Sales plummeted, and the brand had to work hard to clarify the misunderstanding and rebuild trust.

Eskort played no hand in the outbreak — but still lost the round.

This is the unpredictable nature of brand perception. You don’t always win or lose based on your own decisions. Sometimes, the wrong association or the timing of another player’s move changes the outcome entirely.

So how do you play to win?

The best plan is to do whatever you can to stay in the game. You measure, adapt, and regroup. You don’t treat branding like a one-shot campaign with a checkmate in sight. Instead, you learn to read the table, gather signals, and play the long game.

And crucially — you don’t quit just because the last hand didn’t go your way.

Before your next brand play, ask:

  • What assumptions are we betting on?

  • What information are we missing?

  • What’s our response if the odds shift mid-hand?

You also allow for a reasonable amount of flex in your brand — not a compromise on your values, but a willingness to experiment with how you show up in the minds of your audience. Because while we may know some of the variables, we also know there are unknowns — and worse, unknown unknowns. So we brace for them. And we stop swallowing the fairy dust that tells us:

  1. We know exactly who our customers are.

  2. We know exactly who we are to them.

  3. We know exactly where we should play.

  4. We know exactly how we will win.

Because we don’t.

Branding isn’t about perfect control. It’s about strategic resilience.

Dealer, next hand please.


SIGN UP FOR BRANDING SCHOOL

Branding School is a free, 6-part strategic framework that helps you clarify your brand, attract better clients, and create content that converts.

Share this with someone?

LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
Email

GET IN TOUCH

MORE FROM OUR BLOG

Branding

Marketing vs Branding. What’s the difference?

Branding creates advocates. Marketing creates leads.
Branding is long-term. Marketing is short-term.
Branding defines your trajectory. Marketing helps your cash flow.
Branding is about getting people to feel something. Marketing is about getting people to do something.

Read More »
Articles

What to share on social media. Drive engagement now

People will share content because of:

Social Currency: The content allows someone to seem informed, intelligent, progressive or anything that could resonate with their identity.
Triggers: What keeps people talking about things after the fact,

Emotion: Ideas that spark happiness, anger, sadness, whimsy will be shared more than ideas that don’t.

Practical value: It’s built into our DNA, help them survive, and it will thrive.
Story: Information can travel under the guise of what seems to be a story.

Read More »
Articles

How to win with video – Understand watch time

Room 1: The Brand Room is where we ensure the business strategy is aligned with the brand strategy. Room 2: Workshop, Where we create the content, mix, match and replicate things and Room 3: Where we measure the performance of what we have done. This is a glimpse into Room 3; welcome to The Lab. 

Read More »
Articles

7 Free tools to help your brand stand out.

These tools are for anyone who wants to level up their brand’s presence through consistency and overall look. At our studio we use them all the time and now we are sharing them with you! Mahala.

Read More »
Articles

Teach Yourself 100 Setswana Phrases

As someone who can haphazardly butcher my way through a conversation in Sesotho, I have always found it incredibly inspiring to see racial and cultural divides dissolve just because someone can drop a line or two in local vernacular.

Read More »
Articles

What is Content Marketing?

There rests a massive responsibility upon the shoulders of any content creator to be authentic, ethical and honest. We all know that attention is the new currency, but we should never allow hype or gimmicks to wag the dog. Be kind.

Read More »
John-Henry Opperman

Recent Posts

The Social Media Cheat Sheet Every Brand Should Know

If you’re using the same post across LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube, you’re missing the…

8 months ago

Nine Reasons Why Your Business Needs A Brand Film Now

If people enjoy your video ad it increases the likelihood of them buying from you…

1 year ago

Brand Strategy: How To Crush Your Competition

These 5 questions will help define your brand strategy and help you crush your competition.

2 years ago

Marketing vs Branding. What’s the difference?

Branding creates advocates. Marketing creates leads. Branding is long-term. Marketing is short-term. Branding defines your…

2 years ago

What to share on social media. Drive engagement now

People will share content because of: Social Currency: The content allows someone to seem informed, intelligent,…

2 years ago

How to share your podcast with the world

Creating exceptional content is futile if it fails to reach its deserving audience. Identifying and…

2 years ago